Trusted Merchant
Why You Can Shop With Confidence
Shopping online can feel uncertain. Is the product actually handmade in the USA? Is the shop legitimate? Will the quality match the photos? We've all had disappointing experiences. I created this page to share my 15-year ecommerce history so you can feel completely confident shopping with me.
From Artisan to Trusted Merchant
While I may have been born an artisan, I've worked incredibly hard to become a successful online merchant. For 15 years, I've been selling my handcrafted work across the country through trusted online platforms, building a reputation one satisfied customer at a time.
Proven Track Record on Etsy
I operate two successful Etsy shops with thousands of five-star reviews:
Misfit Manor Shop (Est. 2013)
• Nearly 5,000 sales
• Over 1,400 five-star reviews
• 5-star shop rating
• Top 2.8% of Etsy sellers worldwide
Etsy is an incredibly competitive platform for genuine handmade sellers, and I'm proud to have achieved this level of success while maintaining authentic, artisan craftsmanship.
Court Street Journals (Est. November 2023)
• 1,600+ sales
• Nearly 500 five-star reviews
• Top 6.5% of Etsy sellers worldwide
In just over a year, I built Court Street Journals into a top-performing Etsy shop, proving my commitment to quality products and exceptional customer service.
Why I Moved to Shopify
In 2025, I launched this Shopify store for Court Street Journals to better serve you, my valued customers. Here's why:
Better Prices: By avoiding high marketplace fees, I can pass those savings directly to you.
Wider Selection: My Shopify store offers a broader range of products than any single marketplace.
Direct Communication: I can connect with you more personally and respond to your needs faster.
Flexible Policies: I have more control to create customer-friendly policies tailored to your needs.
Long-Term Brand: Building my own store allows me to establish Court Street Journals as a lasting brand you can trust for years to come.
Expanding to Wholesale
In 2025, I also launched a wholesale program, and my artisan book gifts are now carried in over 20 independent bookstores across the country. This partnership with brick-and-mortar retailers is another testament to the quality and appeal of my handcrafted products.
My Promise to You
Every item is genuinely handmade by me in my Kentucky studio. No imports, no mass production, no shortcuts. Just authentic artisan craftsmanship, 15 years of experience, and a commitment to making you smile when you open your package.
Thank you for trusting me with your purchase. I don't take that lightly.
— Nancy, Court Street Journals
